Survey findings: Elective surgery during COVID-19
26 Jun 2020
Thank you to the 1,741 surgeons and surgical trainees who participated in our elective surgery survey, which ran from 8 June to 15 June 2020. The responses have highlighted the range of challenges currently faced by surgical teams, including slow access to test results, continuing difficulty accessing COVID-light facilities and a lack of interdependent services such as diagnostics. In response to these challenges we are making a series of urgent recommendations for action, to restore surgery safely across the country.
- The speed at which test results can be returned is a crucial factor in enabling more elective surgery to take place safely. The aim should be for surgeons to have access to same-day test results, so they can test patients both before and upon admission, and again upon discharge.
- Surgical staff working in COVID-light sites should be tested regularly - up to twice a week where practical.
- Surgical teams in every part of the UK need access to COVID-light sites for their patients, so that people waiting for time-sensitive operations can safely be treated again.
- A quarter of surgical teams depend on the independent sector to provide COVID-light facilities, so contracts with the independent sector need to be extended and include opportunities for surgical trainees to progress their training.
- Good use must continue to be made of recently retired surgeons who have returned to support the NHS through the crisis, with extension of the temporary registers which underpin this.
Survey findings summary
Re-starting elective surgery
- 33% said they had been unable to undertake any elective or planned procedures in the last four weeks. Of those who had resumed surgery, 30% reported that this was only possible for cancer patients.
Barriers cited to restarting elective surgery:
- 46% cited lack of access to interdependent services (such as diagnostics, anaesthesia and sterile processing)
- 35% cited lack of staff
- 33% cited lack of access to testing or swift results
- 21% cited lack of sufficient PPE.
- 62% of survey respondents said that they were able to access COVID-light sites for their patients. However, 26% had not been able to access such facilities at all.
- 26% had accessed COVID-light facilities through the independent sector.
Testing and PPE
- 91% of respondents who had been able to resume planned procedures said that patients were receiving pre-operative tests for COVID-19, in line with recommendations from NHS England.
- 10% of surgeons say that they can get test results for surgical patients within 8 hours, with a further 31% saying test results were available in 24 hours.
- In terms of staff testing, 60% of respondents said they thought it was necessary to test staff at least once a week in order to maintain COVID-light sites.
- One in six (17%) survey respondents said that they did not have a sufficient supply of PPE to do their job safely.
How have surgeons adapted?
- 91% of survey respondents said that they had used video or telephone conferencing to undertake patient consultations and outpatient clinics during the pandemic.
- 83% of surgeons have also conducted team meetings remotely.
- 38% of respondents said that surgeons had been redeployed to alternative roles during the pandemic, and 69% said that there had been redeployment of surgical trainees.
Related resources for surgical teams
- Read our recovery of surgical services guidance, which provides a framework to help manage the backlog of elective operations, and includes additional supporting tools in safety considerations and providing information to patients.
- Our COVID-19 good practice guide addresses adapting surgical services, caring for patients at the end of life, returning to practice, working in an extended scope of practice, and PPE.
- The intercollegiate Clinical guide to surgical prioritisation describes levels of surgical priority.
- Been redeployed? Our COVID-19 learning hub contains a wealth of e-learning to support you.